Clayton’s collection

Who are you?

I'm Clayton Notestine. I'm a writer, critic, and design educator in the tabletop rpg space. I run Explorers Design a design label for educational content on graphic design, mechanics, and industry trends. I've made a few contributions to the industry in the last years, including the Classic Explorer Layout Template.

There was a period, […], when my collection was well over 1,200 pieces.

How would you describe your RPG collection?

Idiosyncratic. Selective. (With a few stragglers I've overlooked.) Not as vast as others might expect. There was a period, while judging in the Ennies, when my collection was well over 1,200 pieces—I donated most of that to my library and traded the rest. My collection is primarily focused on designers I admire, for their POV or their design talents.

How has your collection change over time?

For most of my life, my rpg collection fit in a canvas sack. It was easier to transport whenever I moved for work. There was a period in my teens when I thought I'd hold onto every big book I could get my hands on, but life is too short to collect games you'll never read or play again. To put it another way: shelving is expensive, and 5e takes up too much real estate.

If you could keep only one, which one would it be?

It would have to be the first book I dug out of a yard sale bin: the AD&D Dungeon Master's Guide. I still remember smuggling it under my Catholic grandmother's nose.I can replace nearly everything but that book. Of course, now I'm thinking about Reach of the Roach God... Losing that one would sting.

What’s your most prized item in your collection and why?

It used to be Yazeba's Bed & Breakfast, but I donated that to the library, too. It felt weird having this amazing game—a game with a one-of-a-kind experience and perspective—collecting dust next to my dungeon books. My guess is that my most valuable item in the collection is Reach of the Roach God which is out of print and will never be printed again. Last I checked, it was selling for $500.

What game opened your eyes in some way, and how?

Nearly every book in my collection earned its spot by surprising me, but Silent Titans is probably the single biggest influence on me in ways I'm still unravelling. The typesetting and the way it uses bullet points are a capital offense, mind you, but everything else about it is still waiting to be repeated. It's personal, cerebral, discombobulating, and yet so tactile. Someday. Someday. Someday.

Silent Titans is probably the single biggest influence on me in ways I'm still unravelling. The typesetting and the way it uses bullet points are a capital offense, mind you […]

A game you’ve changed your mind about?

There's a voice in the back of my head that says, "Some of these companies don't deserve the games they're stewarding." Now I'm not saying every company should be like Tuesday Knight Games—that would be asking too much, but I mostly hold onto my Pendragon and Runequest books out of sentimentality. Sometimes I crack them open and wonder what it would be like to keep everything but the mechanics. I think me and the loyalists are divided. I think Runequest would be more like the Runequest I remember if it we changed it.

Favorite non-rulebook, non-adventure book that you’d still consider part of the collection?

My non-rpg books are the biggest contributors to my games and they're squirreled away everywhere, on shelves, under my bed, in my car door, propping up flower pots—name a place and I have a book or piece of media wedged inside of it. My favorite non-rulebooks that I'd consider part of my collection? Every book I own by Terry Pratchett and Raymond Chandler. The former is my favorite fantasy author—the weirdest, slyest worldbuilder of all time. The latter can write characterization that'll make you laugh and spit on your own carpet.

Favorite set of dice?

A set of orange dice with black numbering. They're probably off balance somehow. I rummaged them out of a pound of dice in college and I've yet to find any dice with a color scheme I like more. They fool me into thinking I'm not materialistic.

What's your note-taking setup, both as a player and as a GM? What notebook do you use? What pen?

I use dot grid paper with tear away pages from Fabriano. It's an Italian stationary brand. For writing I use Blackwing and Mitsubishi pencils. They smell like art class and scratch nice dark lines onto the paper without me having to form some kind of antagonistic relationship.

Show us your digital collection and/or talk about it a bit.

It's my dark secret. Full of pdfs of games I haven't played or read. For the longest time, I preferred PDFs because they don't go through TSA like my canvas sack of books do, but I've since changed my mind, and I hardly look at them.

Who would you like to see a Shelfie from?

Seraphina over on Dice Exploder probably has a collection with names I've never heard of. I'd love to peruse her collection.